Skip To Main Content

Manhattanville University Athletics

scoreboard

Jeff Caulfield

Career Record
Years: 21
Record: 413-383-2 (.519)
NCAA Appearances
2007, 2010
Conference Championships
Skyline: 2007
MAC Freedom: 2010
Honors and Awards
Skyline Conf. Coach of the Year
2005, 2007
Freedom Conf. Coach of the Year
2009, 2014, 2019
All-America Selections
ABCA: 1
D3baseball.com: 1
All-Region Selections
ABCA All-Region: 18
D3baseball.com All-Region: 6
ECAC All-Stars: 13
All-Conference Selections
Skyline: 30
MAC Freedom: 62
The second-winningest coach in Manhattanville history and one of the longest-tenured leaders at the college, Jeff Caulfield completed his 21st season at the helm of the Valiant baseball program in 2025.

A five-time conference Coach of the Year, Caulfield has coached two All-Americans, four Conference Players of the Year and 90 All-Conference selections.  Manhattanville has had at least one All-Region pick in 13 of Caulfield's 20 years at the helm, and 24 of the program’s 26 ABCA or D3baseball.com All-Region honorees have come under his successful watch.

One of only four coaches (along with current head softball coach Dale Martin) ever to coach a sport at Manhattanville for at least 13 seasons, he became the department's all-time leader in career wins with his 203rd career victory on April 13, 2014 at FDU-Florham and currently ranks second in Manhattanville history in total wins.

In 2010, Caulfield guided the Valiants to the program’s first Freedom Conference Tournament championship and second NCAA Tournament berth with a 22-21-1 overall record, the team’s fourth straight year with a conference regular-season or tournament title. Six players were honored with spots on the All-Conference team, including Freedom Player of the Year Paul Blejec, who was one of four first-team selections and also was named to the ABCA All-Mid-Atlantic Region team. Dan Fiorito also became the first player in program history to earn All-America honors with an honorable mention from D3baseball.com.

Caulfield led the Valiants to the first Skyline Conference regular-season and tournament championships in program history in 2007, guiding Manhattanville to the NCAA Tournament for the first time. The team finished the year ranked seventh in the New York Region and was comprised mainly of young talent recruited by Caulfield, as six of the Valiants' nine starters were freshmen or sophomores. As a result, Caulfield was named Skyline Coach of the Year for a second time and the Valiants earned seven All-Conference honorees, including five on the first team, and a program-record five ABCA All-Region selections.

In his first season of 2005, Caulfield led the Valiants to a 23-15 mark, setting a program record for wins by a first-year coach and earning Skyline Conference Coach of the Year honors for the first time. He also coached a program-record eight All-Conference honorees, including an amazing six players on the All-Skyline first team.

Before taking the head coaching reigns of the Valiant program, Caulfield worked as an assistant at Manhattanville from 2002-04, serving as the team's pitching coach.

A 2000 graduate of New York Region power Cortland State, Caulfield was a part of the Red Dragon team for five seasons as a player and coach, helping the team to the College World Series in each year. Caulfield also earned his master's degree from Mercy College in 2004.

 
Overall Conf.
Year W L T W L Postseason
2005 23 15 12 4 Skyline (4th)
2006 22 19 13 5 Skyline (4th), ECACs (1st Round)
2007 23 19 14 4 Skyline (1st), NCAAs (0-2)
2008 28 13 14 4 Freedom (2nd)
2009 26 17 11 5 Freedom (2nd)
2010 22 21 1 12 9 Freedom (1st), NCAAs (0-2)
2011 16 21 7 14
2012 16 22 9 12 Freedom (3rd)
2013 14 29 9 12 Freedom (3rd)
2014 24 16 13 8 Freedom (2nd), ECACs (1st Round)
2015 23 18 14 7 Freedom (4th)
2016 25 16 13 8 MACF (3rd)
2017 18 23 10 11 MACF (3rd)
2018 16 18 1 11 10
2019 24 18 14 7 MACF (3rd)
2020 5 5 season incomplete
2021 12 11 9 7
2022 19 19 11 9 Skyline (1st Round)
2023 17 22 10 10
2024 20 21 11 9 Skyline (Dbl. Elim. Finals)
2025 20 20 10 9 Skyline (1st Round)
Career  413 383 2 227 164



















Â