Skip To Main Content

Manhattanville University Athletics

scoreboard

Kathleen O'Mara readies at free throw line
Mallory Agner
72
Manhattanville MANHATTA 0-2
75
Winner Fitchburg St. FITCHBUR 3-0
Manhattanville MANHATTA
0-2
72
Final
75
Fitchburg St. FITCHBUR
3-0
Winner
Score By Periods
Team 1 2 3 4 OT 1 F
Manhattanville MANHATTA 18 16 16 17 5 72
Fitchburg St. FITCHBUR 20 16 13 18 8 75

Game Recap: Women's Basketball | | John Ewen, Director of Athletic Communications

O'Mara Scores Career-High 27 in Women's Basketball Overtime Loss at Fitchburg State

FITCHBURG, Mass. – Kathleen O'Mara (Huntington, N.Y./Walt Whitman) scored a career-high 27 and pulled down ten rebounds for her first double-double of the season, but the junior's leading performance was not enough for the Manhattanville University women's basketball team on Sunday as the Valiants fell 75-72 at Fitchburg State in overtime. Manhattanville falls to 0-2 to open the season.

O'Mara shot 65 percent from the field, playing all 45 minutes in the overtime tilt. The junior reached double-digit rebound totals for the sixth time in her career and added five steals, three assists and a block to her loaded statline.

O'Mara was joined in double-figures by Jaylyn Orefice (Union City, N.J./Jose Marti STEM Academy) and Charlotte March (Tappan, N.Y./Tappan Zee High School). Orefice scored 16 in her second game with the Valiants, hitting five field goals while going 6-for-6 at the free throw line. March, meanwhile, scored 10 in her 34 minutes off the bench.

Katie Purpura (Richboro, Pa./Council Rock South) came down with seven boards while dishing out seven assists. Kaitlyn Mangan (New Fairfield, Conn./New Fairfield) also generated offense with six assists to go with nine points and five rebounds.

The Valiants were held in check from deep, going just 2-for-18 on three-point attempts. It was the fewest three-pointers scored by Manhattanville since Jan. 9, 2026, where they were also limited to a pair against Saint Joseph's Long Island, while the .111 field goal percentage from beyond the arc was the team's lowest since Dec. 7, 2024 against Sarah Lawrence (3-for-27, .111).

Sunday was the Valiants' first overtime contest since Dec. 4, 2024. Manhattanville has lost each of its last seven games that have gone to overtime dating back a decade, with their last win in extra time coming against King's on Feb. 6, 2016.

As to be expected in a game that went to overtime, Sunday's affair was tightly contested from the opening tip, with the largest lead of the game being just seven points. Fitchburg opened play with the first two baskets of the contest before a Taylor Malone (Yonkers, N.Y./Kennedy Catholic Prep) layup and an O'Mara old-fashioned three point play gave the Valiants their first lead of the game. The Valiants maintained the slim advantage for most of the quarter, helped by a Mangan three that put Manhattanville up 16-12 with 3:11 on the clock. Fitchburg responded with six unanswered points to retake the lead before the sides traded free throws to close out the quarter, with Manhattanville's March and Fitchburg's Laila Jackson each hitting both shots from the stripe to put the Falcons up 20-18 at the horn.

Manhattanville went nearly six minutes across the quarters without a field goal as Fitchburg built up a six-point lead. March ended the Valiants' cold spell with a layup, but Cali Laliberte hit a pair of three-pointers to give the home team its largest lead of the game at 30-23 with 5:23 left in the half. The Valiants erased the deficit at the free throw line, going 7-for-8 to close out the half to tie the score at 34-34. The Falcons responded with a Laila Jackson jumper at the buzzer to retake the lead into the break.

An O'Mara steal set up a Malone three to open up the second half scoring, putting the Valiants in front. After two more tied scores, the Valiants took their largest lead of the game with a 7-2 run, going up 46-41 with 2:45 left in the third. Fitchburg responded with eight-straight points, fueled by threes from Wynter Jones and Jackson, but Manhattanville would lead 50-49 entering the fourth, thanks to a pair of Mangan free throws and an Arsela Mustafaj (Yonkers, N.Y./Yonkers Montessori Academy) layup.

Fitchburg took a 57-52 lead with 7:25 left in regulation before the Valiants scored seven-unanswered points to go ahead by two on an O'Mara layup. The teams fought to three different tied scores as the clock dipped under a minute, evened at 65-65 with 26 seconds to play. Erin Dixon put the home side ahead with a layup, but Orefice delivered for the Valiants on the other end with a pair of free throws to send the game to overtime.

The Falcons scored first in the extra period on a Dixon layup and a Winter free throw. Manhattanville tied the game on a pair of free throws by O'Mara and a first hit by Purpura. The Valiants looked to have taken the lead as Purpura's second attempt also went in, but Manhattanville was called for a violation, erasing the try and keeping the game even at 70-70. Kyelah Smith cashed in for Fitchburg with a three with 1:52 left in OT, a final deficit that proved to be too much for the Valiants to fight back from. Manhattanville missed its final three field goal attempts as Fitchburg held on for the 75-72 win.

Up Next
The Valiants return home on Wednesday night to host Ramapo at 6 p.m.

VALIANTS on SOCIAL MEDIA For the latest on Manhattanville Athletics, follow the Valiants via social media on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, Threads and YouTube. #WeAreValiant #GoValiants

Print Friendly Version